Alfredo’s Restaurant

4.8 (127 reviews )
$$
Italian restaurant
Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
+(12)

About Alfredo’s Restaurant

Alfredo’s Restaurant, located at 189 S Main St, New City, NY, is a beloved Italian eatery known for its consistently delicious dishes and warm, inviting atmosphere. With a focus on fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, diners rave about the creamy Alfredo sauce and innovative cocktails, like the must-try strawberry lemon drop martini. The attentive staff contributes to a top-notch dining experience, ensuring every meal is memorable. Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual outing, Alfredo's combination of great food and friendly service keeps guests coming back for more. Reservations are recommended, given its popularity.

Reviews (127) 4.8

  • Alex H
    Jun 23,2025

    Wow, haven’t been here since Covid so I was extremely excited to return especially for a family member’s birthday and it certainly didn’t disappoint. The food & drinks were spot on and the service was top notch. Will certainly be returning soon!

  • Doze2Katzs LLC
    Jun 8,2025

    The food here was very good, all four of us who went enjoyed our meal selections I really enjoyed my appetizer and my main meal and it was plenty of food that I took home a nice leftover meal. . also had an after dinner drink. The tiramisu martini, that drink is soooooo good! The only gripe was it was busy and only two staff working for all tables. It took a while for them to take our orders. I will definitely return for another time.

  • Jaime Armida
    May 27,2025

    The food is always consistently good! It is one of our go to places for Italian. I love their Alfredo! The strawberry lemon drop martini is a must get! They have outdoor dining in the nice weather. All of the staff works hard and are always nice and friendly. You won’t be disappointed!!!

  • Amanda Hahn
    May 5,2025

    Alfredos is always 10/10 no matter what dish you order. They know how to make a lemon drop martini like no other! The staff is top notch. One of my ultimate favorite restaurants!!

  • Richard
    Apr 17,2025

    In the heart of New City, NY. This Italian restaurant stands out far above the rest. A professional staff, Italian cuisine, and the atmosphere sets the mode for a delicious Italian meal. You won't be disappointed. Come with a appetite. Leave satisfied.

  • Michael Grossberg
    Mar 25,2025

    Such amazing food!! We had the clams as an appetizer, the veal chop Milanese and the chicken rigatoni with the champagne sauce. We practically licked all the plates clean! Highly recommend!!

  • Matt Florence
    Mar 13,2025

    I said to my wife we don't eat here often enough. Everything is always delicious, the flavored oil with the bread is delicious, a glass of wine is reasonable, and the dishes from a huge menu are all very good. Same staff every time you go, and everyone works together and is very friendly. I highly recommend Alfredo's as a place to go for a great dinner at a good price, and my wife and I will start eating there more! Always a good idea to call at least a few days ahead to get a reservation, as it fills up quick.

  • Gianni DD
    Mar 13,2025

    We went for the first time on our anniversary the day before Valentine's day. Without a reservation we got lucky and got a 2 top. Places was smaller than I expected not that I did alot of research before hand. Service was good and food was really good. There is parking but we got a spot in the street out front. The bar is long and would be a nice casual area to dine. We will definitely be going back.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Alfredo's Restaurant?

    Customers rave about the Alfredo pasta, veal chop Milanese, and the standout tiramisu martini. Many also love the clams appetizer!

  • Do I need a reservation to dine at Alfredo's?

    It's recommended to make a reservation, especially on busy nights, to secure a table as it fills up quickly.

  • Can I get takeout at Alfredo's Restaurant?

    Yes, Alfredo's offers takeout, making it easy for you to enjoy their delicious Italian cuisine at home.

  • What is the atmosphere like at Alfredo's?

    Alfredo's has a cozy and casual vibe, perfect for family dinners or a night out with friends. Outdoor seating is available during nice weather!

  • Is parking available at Alfredo's Restaurant?

    Yes, there's free parking available in their lot, as well as free street parking nearby.

Nearby Italian restaurants

Italian restaurant
La Grotta

811 McLean Ave, Yonkers, NY 10704, United States

Italian restaurant
Attilio's

770 James St, Syracuse, NY 13203, United States

Italian restaurant
Calarco's Restaurant & Lounge

15 Market St, Westfield, NY 14787, United States

Italian restaurant
BOCO Kitchen

7375 Boston State Rd, Hamburg, NY 14075, United States

Italian restaurant
Sette Mezzo

969 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10021 United States

Italian restaurant
Sal D's

208 Wall St Huntington, NY 11743 United States

Italian restaurant
Da Noi Restaurant on Victory Blvd

4358 Victory Blvd Staten Island, NY 10314 United States

Italian restaurant
Primola Restaurant

1226 2nd Ave New York, NY 10065 United States

Italian restaurant
Pasta-Pasta

2023 Williamsbridge Rd Bronx, NY 10461 United States

Italian restaurant
Milano Restaurant

594 New Loudon Rd Latham, NY 12110 United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page